Review of my 2025 ‘Walking Away’ chapbook by Jean Atkin

This new review of my Dare-Gale Press chapbook, ‘WALKING AWAY’, written by Jean Atkin, has just been posted on the London Grip website in November 2026. My thanks to Jean and to London Grip’s editor, Michael Bartholomew-Biggs.

This is a beautifully designed and produced pamphlet from Dare-Gale Press, a pleasure to hold in the hands. The greater part of Crucefix’s slim book is devoted to the title poem in the form of a sequence of haiku, which offer condensed thoughts and memories from that hard place in life, when parents become frail.

The haiku sequence is bookended by a longer poem at the beginning, and two at the end. The first, “Video Call”, consists of two twelve-line stanzas which introduce the reader to Crucefix’s elderly parents. The poem first evokes ‘that familiar image/ of a banking Spitfire beyond their shoulders’, a marker of the war that ‘bound them sixty years together’. But then we are fetched to the difficult present, the ‘struggling to unmute’, and ‘sometimes the laptop screen/ is angled so I catch only the crowns// of grey heads’. I found this poem beautiful in its restraint, and poignant in the son’s awareness and kindliness towards narrowed and repetitive older lives – ‘still talking blithely asking me still/ if I can see these crocuses’.

The haiku sequence begins by exploring a measure of years in the forty foot height of a tree ‘a willow you once carried home’ – and then the essential smallness of ‘This week’s new dosette box/ Grey windows not yet broken’. Limitations appear on every side, the poet says simply ‘I’ve no map to your mind’.  Tea grows cold, a clock ticks, memory and recognition fades. Then a marvellous, terrible haiku –

You invent a new language

A shrew’s paw in a trap
A bubbling sound in your throat

I notice each haiku has either the first or last of its three lines separated by a line from the other two. This simple technique adds indicators, sometimes of time passing, or of a change of view or direction – and serves to deepen the reading experience. Confusion is suggested by simile – ‘As at a level crossing/ Days pass’ and then that line space before ‘Who are the other passengers?’ The struggle to cope with the passage of time, to mark time, is repeatedly explored – in the days crossed out in black on a large print calendar, for example, or ‘Scratching of the same mouse// Morning and evening/ The central heating comes on’.

Though capital letters provide shape to the haikus, the absence of full stops is striking, and feels appropriate, suggesting drift, a lack of definition.  The son, the carer, is an observer of small acts and the struggle against loss of agency:

This at your right hand is dirty
Soon on the left what is clean

Clarity at the sink

The haiku sequence makes us familiar with the house – ‘Dining chair and the coffee table/ Shifted here and there’; and the microwave ping; and ‘A scuffling in the eaves’. Mirrors repeat their presence: in the son’s old room are ‘Mirrors you never find empty’; and again ‘Four mirrors in the wardrobe doors/ Four versions of yourself’; and again ‘Mirrors see and repeat forever/ Their angles change’. Old age is a time of reflection, but also of the narrowing of view.

The weight of responsibility has fully passed to the son, who because the road runs beside the railway line, looks ‘towards the fast-moving train// I know it’s a risk.’ The final haiku expresses the inevitability of the situation, and how life continues too.

Time – I can’t persuade you of it
Your parents walking away

The felled apple tree in blossom

The pamphlet concludes with a poem for the poet’s mother, created ‘as Cleopatra’s Monument’ a narrow obelisk of words: ‘a blue plastic jug/ its blue plastic cup… ‘a glint on the foil/ of today’s medication’. And propped in bed ‘an Easter Island profile/ gaunt and beaked’. The poet keeps vigil ‘with all the helpless-/ ness of a Charmian at the cooling feet/ of her brave Queen’.

For his father, the rhythmically beautiful ‘”In This Quiet One-way West Country Town”, in which the long father and son relationship is examined.

It’s closing time along the pavements where
we walk at half past five hand in hand
as you never did with your own father
(hand in hand as the two of us never did either)

Yet this is the place ‘where you were happiest’ and the calm, or at least the regularity and quiet endurance of these lives is gently respected, as the poem ends with traditional words of comfort:

now it’s closing time
all across this quiet provincial one-way
west country town turning for home before dark.

Martin Crucefix tackles this hard experience in most people’s lives with honesty, tenderness and great sensitivity. His poetry is unobtrusively crafted, and his graceful phrasing never hesitates when faced with the losses and indignities of old age.

Jean Atkin

Should I Send My Poems to Magazines or Competitions?

Issue 87 (January 2017) of Acumen has just appeared including Shanta Acharya’s interview with Indian poet and short story writer, Keki Deruwalla, plus reviews of books by Alice Oswald, Carol Rumens, Liz Lochhead, Tony Curtis and the first tranche of books from Little Island Press. There are also poems from Tony Curtis, Norbert Hirschhorn, Harry Guest, Duncan Forbes, Deruwalla and many others and translations of Verlaine, Tsiakos and Catullus. As well as this, Acumen editor, Patricia Oxley asked a number of poets (myself included) to comment on the relative importance of publication in magazines and winning (or placing) in poetry competitions. Which of the two is most important or advantageous?

 

keki-daruwalla_1
Keki Deruwalla

 

In his piece, Christopher North feels poems go to competitions first as the rewards of winning are greater than a mere appearance in a magazine. But for himself, he prefers to read poems in “gangs” or small portfolios (most likely to be found in magazines or chapbooks). North voices a common concern that the isolated poem (in a competition) is not always the best guide to a poet’s true worth. Hilary Davies’ piece suggests much the same thing, strongly praising the role of the magazine and its editor for having an eye not for the spectacular one-off, but for the longer term: “they have a stake in bringing on and nurturing new poets . . . there is a depth to the activities of the editor”, she argues, in stark contrast to the competition judge however thoroughly they do their job.

imgres

Davies also regrets the existence of the ‘competition’ poem that we are all so familiar with – the 40 lines, any subject, the successful mostly with a powerful narrative drive or end-of-poem punch. None of these elements are bad in themselves but Davies argues persuasively that “competitions unintentionally reinforce a formulaic and limited understanding of what constitutes a good poem”. Evidently, she sides with the magazines (see my recent review of Davies most recent collection). In contrast, Martin Malone confesses he’s not so sure where he stands though he acknowledges that competition wins “do provide a fast-track means of ‘getting-on’ in an age besotted with instant success”. The imagery he uses to express this – that we live on Planet Gadget and how we cannot but love our bells and whistles – makes clear his scepticism about the ultimate value of such winning poems. But Malone is clearer than most about the importance that winning competitions can often have on a poet’s career these days.

imgres

Caroline Carver’s piece is rather more celebratory in tone, suggesting the modern world of poetry presents writers with an “increasing choice” of outlets in terms of publication in print, or on-line or via competition entry. But the ease of the mouse click also means that the competitiveness and crowdedness of the market increases. Nevertheless, sounding admirably un-angsty about the topic, she says (assuming one has enough material available) a mix of both magazine submissions and competition entries is the safe way ahead. And for those who suffer repeated set-backs she refers us to the newly-launched website Salon of the Refused.

imgres

Michael Bartholomew-Biggs is both poet and editor of the on-line magazine London Grip. He puts forward what I think is the generally-expressed view here that “a publication record reveals more about a poet’s consistency and range than a prize – or even a few prizes”. Following the logic of this, he squares the circle by suggesting that the type of competition (which seems ever more common) that offers prizes and publication for a “portfolio” of poems seems to be “a distinct and valid route to recognition”. My contribution argued something like Bartholomew-Biggs’ view though rather more cynically suggested that winning prizes, in part through the likely resulting prominence through social media, might well weigh more heavily with a more commercially-driven publishing house. Overall, these six writers seem to feel a track record of publication in magazines is still the best guide to a poet’s quality and worth, though there is equally a clear anxiety expressed that competition-winning is becoming (or has already become) more used as a means of sifting through the submissions of collections for publication.

To read this discussion in full go to the Acumen website and subscribe!